Keto Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

What’s A Keto Red Velvet Cake?

A red velvet cake is way more than a vanilla cake with red color. It is a moist, vanilla cocoa cake with a subtle flavor of buttermilk.

This keto red velvet recipe has all of these without the carbs or sugar. It uses almond milk and apple cider vinegar to mimic classic buttermilk.

The secret for a moist low-carb cake crumb is to use ultra-fine almond flour, not almond meal.

How To Make Keto Red Velvet Cake

This very easy red velvet cake recipe is made with just a few simple ingredients.

But before you start baking this amazing keto cake, there are a few simple things you need to know to make sure you get the most delicious cake.

Preparing The Ingredients

This is a standard for any keto baking recipe. In fact, if you don’t use ingredients at room temperature, your batter can end up ultra-thick or lumpy.

So what does it means to bring ingredients to room temperature, you would ask?

Well, it means taking all the ingredients out of the fridge at least 3 hours before you start baking.

• Eggs – if you want to bring eggs to room temperature quickly, you can immerse them in a hot water bath for 20 minutes. Of course, don’t use boiling water, or you will cook the eggs! Otherwise, the best method is to place the eggs out of the fridge the day before baking the cake or at least 3 hours before baking.
• Butter and cream cheese – to soften butter or cream cheese quickly, I recommend measuring the amount called by the recipe. Then, cut the block of butter or cream cheese into small cubes. Finally, store the cubes of butter or cream cheese in a bowl on the kitchen countertop for at least 3 hours or overnight. You know your butter is ready when it is ultra-soft. If you squeeze it with your fingers, it melts easily.
• Other ingredients – if you usually store flour or erythritol in the fridge, take it out the day before or 3 hours before baking.

Ingredients

• Almond Flour – An almond meal is coarse and would not be a good fit for this cake. It would dry the cake crumb, making it dense and not moist at all. So use ultra-fine almond flour.
• Erythritol – or allulose or a blend of Monk fruit and erythritol. Note that erythritol decreases the ingredients’ temperature. Read more about it in my keto sweetener article. Therefore, if you bake this cake in winter, make sure your house is between 68°F and 72°F (20°C-22°C), or erythritol can solidify butter, forming lumps.
• Liquid natural red food coloring – if you want to use food coloring powder instead of liquid coloring, add 1 1/2 tablespoons of unsweetened almond milk to compensate.
• Large eggs – as mentioned above, they must be at room temperature and large. In fact, using small eggs results in a dry cake crumb.
•  Butter  – soft at room temperature. Read my paragraph above for more details about how to bring butter to room temperature quickly.
• Light olive oil – or any nut or seed oil like avocado oil, almond oil, or grape seed oil. I don’t recommend using coconut oil in this recipe simply because it firms up when in contact with unsweetened cocoa powder.
• Unsweetened cocoa powder
• Baking powder – this is a gluten-free keto cake, so it won’t rise much. Gluten protein is what reacts with baking powder and raises cakes a lot. The baking powder will react with apple cider vinegar to add a lighter texture to the cake layer. Don’t expect a high-raising layer like a regular red velvet cake, though.
• Vanilla extract
• Unsweetened almond milk or unsweetened coconut milk.
• Apple cider vinegar – the specificity of red velvet cakes is the buttermilk flavor. Since this is a keto cake recipe, we don’t use dairy, buttermilk contains sugar from lactose, so it is better to avoid it on a keto diet. As a replacement, we use apple cider vinegar and unsweetened almond milk. It adds a similar buttermilk flavor to the cake without the carbs.

Making The Keto Velvet Cake Batter

It is an easy 4-step keto cake recipe.

Let me guide you through each step, including any cake troubleshooting tips to help you achieve the tastiest red velvet cake.

Step 1: beat butter and sweetener

First, you have to beat the soft butter and sweetener with an electric beater or stand mixer using the whisk attachment.

That’s very easy to do, but if your butter is hard, half-soft, or cold, you can get into trouble.

Plus, if your sweetener is crystal erythritol, it can result in serious butter lumps.

In fact, erythritol is known for its endothermic reaction, which means it decreases the temperature of ingredients coming in contact with it.

So, if you also use butter that is not soft enough or too cold, this problem will be exacerbated.

To troubleshoot this, bring the bowl into a bain-marie, and read my recipe card note to learn more about removing butter lumps.

Step 2- add eggs

Next, you must add eggs one by one into the beaten butter. As above, if eggs are not cold, you won’t have a problem achieving a lump-free batter.

Also, always add eggs quickly every 15 seconds to decrease the beating time which could lead to lumps too.

Step 3: oil and cocoa powder

In another bowl, you will combine oil, red food coloring, and unsweetened cocoa powder. While you could add this directly into the previous batter, I recommend stirring these 3 ingredients together first.

In fact, this will ensure that the cocoa powder dissolves well and avoid bitter lumps of unsweetened cocoa powder.

The only trick here is to use an oil that is liquid at room temperature, so coconut oil is not a good choice. The best keto oils to use in this keto cake recipe are light olive oil, avocado oil, or almond oil.

Step 4: combine all ingredients 

Finally, bring all the ingredients together using the electric beater on low speed or a stand mixer.

You know the batter is ready when it is read/pinkish in color, smooth and liquid.

It shouldn’t be thick. This would mean you are missing some liquid.

Baking The Best Keto Cake

This keto red velvet cake is a two-layer cake. Therefore, you will bake each cake layer into separate 9-inch round non-stick pans.

Grease the pan

It is crucial to double grease the pan to prevent the batter from sticking to the pan.

First, spray oil all over the cake pan.

Then, lay a circle piece of parchment paper at the bottom of each pan. Finally, respray some oil.

Fill the pan

To create 2 layers of the same thickness, you should add the same amount of cake batter to each cake pan.

For this keto cake recipe, it means adding about 2 cups of cake batter to each pan.

Baking Time 

There are two ways to bake your keto red velvet cake, regular more or convection mode.

Whatever mode you choose, don’t change the temperature for this keto cake recipe.

Simply note that convection mode bakes 5-8 minutes faster.

First, set the oven to 325°F (160°C) and place the cake pans on the center rack of the oven.

Then, bake for 25-30 minutes, checking the baking time after 20 minutes with a skewer.

Finally, remove the cake from the oven when the skewer comes out dry or with just a few crumbs on it. It means the cake is cooked through.

Cooldown

To prevent the cake from sticking to the pan, it is better to unmold the cake shortly after taking it out of the oven. 5 minutes is the ideal time.

You may have to run a knife around the edge of the pan to loosen the cake if it sticks slightly.

Decorating Low-Carb Red Velvet Cake

Like most red velvet cakes, this keto cake uses a cream cheese frosting.

However, this is a sugar-free cream cheese frosting using powdered erythritol, butter, and vanilla extract.

As a result, it is an almost zero-carb frosting, and any leftover can be used as a sweet keto snack!

Sugar-free cream cheese icing

A cake turntable is very convenient for decorating layer cakes. I love to use this for my keto chocolate cake or keto vanilla cake recipes too.

First, place the first layer of cake on the turning table.

Next, add 1/3 of the frosting to the center of the cake. Then, turn the table with one hand and hold a spreading tool with the other hand to press/spread the frosting as you turn.

Finally, add the last cake layer and repeat the frosting spreading process until fully covered with icing.

Cake crumb

I love to decorate the sides of this low-carb red velvet cake with cake crumbs.  Usually, red velvet cake layers raise a lot in the middle.

So the layers are leveled with a knife, and the leftover cake crumb is used as a decoration.

However, keto cake layers don’t raise much, and you don’t have any leftover cake crumbs.

My secret is to set aside 1/4 cup of cake batter and bake it for 10 minutes on a tray covered with greased parchment paper.

It results in a thin layer of red velvet batter that you can crumble into pieces and use as cake decoration.

Storage Instructions

This recipe serves a double-layer keto cake with 12 slices. Therefore, you won’t be able to eat the whole cake quickly, except if it is a celebration cake to share.

The good news, you can freeze the leftover keto cake slices in airtight containers.

Or, simply store the cake in a cake box in the fridge for up to 3 days.